In Star Tournaments only the combined card is eligible to be used. The following players have more than one card with the minimum requirements, but only the combined card can be used. The combined card will always have the most AB or IP.
| Eligible Card | Ineligible Card | |||
| Player | Team | AB | Team | AB |
| Bay,J | BOA | 577 | PIN | 393 |
| Blake,C | LAN | 536 | CLA | 325 |
| Bautista,J | TOA | 370 | TOA | 314 |
| Griifey,K | CHA | 490 | CIN | 359 |
| Kotchman,C | ATN | 525 | LAA | 373 |
| Kotsay,M | BOA | 402 | ATN | 318 |
| Nady,X | NYA | 555 | PIN | 327 |
| Ramirez,M | LAN | 552 | BOA | 385 |
| Stairs,M | PHN | 337 | TOA | 320 |
| Teixeira,M | LAA | 574 | ATN | 381 |
| Eligible Card | Ineligible Card | |||
| Pitcher | Team | IP | Team | IP |
| Baek,C | SDN | 141 | SDN | 111 |
| Bautista,D | PIN | 60 | PIN | 41 |
| Blanton,J | PHN | 198 | OAA | 127 |
| Gallagher,S | OAA | 115 | CHN | 59 |
| Gaudin | CHN | 90 | OAA | 63 |
| Grilli | CON | 75 | CON | 61 |
| Hawkins,L | HON | 62 | NYA | 41 |
| Hernandez,L | CON | 160 | MNA | 140 |
| Marte,D | NYA | 65 | PIN | 47 |
| Masset,N | CIN | 62 | CHA | 45 |
| Ohlendorf,R | PIN | 63 | NYA | 40 |
| Sabathia,C | MLN | 253 | MLN | 131 |
| Tavarez,J | ATN | 55 | ATN | 42 |
| Tomko,B | SDN | 70 | KCA | 61 |